Sunday, September 16, 2012

Universal Design Challenge

Universal Design...
... is difficult to retrofit. I chose to live in my current apartment, shown here with walk-up stoop, because I admire the historic brownstone and greystone architecture of the area of Harlem where I now reside. Well, that, and the affordable rent and convenience to the nearby train station. I did not have in mind Universal Design when choosing said apartment, but for as long as I have lived in New York thus far, I have not lived in one that would could be called UD. As you can see in the photo above, the stairs are not universally friendly, and neither are the heavy old double doors. There are more stairs once you enter to my second floor walk-up. The building has no elevator, no ramp, and the doors require two hands to enter the heavy doors which must be held open as you enter; they do not stay open of their own accord.
      When it comes to principles of UD, I think of new buildings with ramps and elevators which are accessible to all. I think of doors that are wide and have buttons or sensors for automatic entrance. I think of clean, contemporary buildings designed to accommodate large numbers of people, with various physical differences and capabilities. Often, the buildings which come to mind are hospitals, libraries, and contemporary museums. In certain instances, I see public transportation stations and vehicles which are accommodating with ramps, pneumatic lifts, automatic doors, and elevators. The limitations, however, I see everywhere. Stairs, stairs, stairs. Tight areas. High-reaching sinks, cabinets, and shelves. Heavy doors. The list goes on. Especially, when it comes to older, historic buildings. I tend to like and appreciate the aesthetic of old brick and mortar buildings, brownstones, and the like. But had I any physical limitation or disability, would I still feel the same way? Or would these restrictive beauties built of oppressive ornamentation produce anxiety upon approach? Perhaps I would strongly prefer the contemporary, clean, modern design of (most) buildings and areas built in respect to Universal Design. It is a thing for me to consider for the next time I find a place to live or work... how would I, or a friend or relative or acquaintance, physically navigate this setting? Can changes be made if it is not navigable in some way? And I must consider how I can be more aware of the importance of universal accessibility.

3 comments:

  1. Cristina, I totally agree with you. Part of the charm of living in NYC is that you can live in a beautiful pre-war building/brownstone. But of course, this presents a problem to modern day residents with the all the stairs, heavy doors, narrow hallways, etc. My grandmother recently lost the use of her left leg after a stroke, and UDL has been on my mind a lot lately due to it. We can install stair lifts and what not, but what will that do to the aesthetic history and architecture of the building? There must be a common ground, because a lot of these make-shift options are expensive and unattractive.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Christina,
    I definitely agree with Judy. The charm of living in NYC is being able to walk down a tree-lined street and see all of those beautiful brownstones. Sometimes incorporating form and function into the same thing is very difficult. That being said, there are ways to create ramps and things that match the architecture of the building. That could definitely be something worth considering to keep the integrity of the brownstone charm while still making it functional for all people.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I realized that we can make just about anything look "vintage" if we try hard enough. Perhaps installing a stainless steal ramp on one of these brownstones would be an eyesore to some. I think it is possible to create a ramp that serves its necessary function while maintaining the look and feel of a pre-war building. The contractor could try to use the same materials used to make the stairs so that it doesn't look so out of place. On the other hand, who cares if it doesn't match? Accommodations and adaptations are a necessary part of life that should be acknowledged.

    ReplyDelete